|
|
|
| |
DFB offers drug
and alcohol courses in four formats — online,
CD-ROM, instructor-led (i.e., classroom style) and newsletters.
Each type has pros and cons, and works best for some
situations and companies. Here's some help in thinking
through what's right for you.
To start, here are some
factors to consider as
you make your training decision.
Instructor-led training
can be engaging and interactive, especially if the material is solid and the instructor
is knowledgeable and skilled. But it can also be costly
when you include the impact of lost time and production. Plus, it's not easily scalable for large companies.
Printed training — such as workbooks and newsletters — can be
can be economical for smaller companies. They can be relatively inexpensive to purchase and
don't disrupt workplace routines like classroom training. However, they can be
more difficult to administer and track in larger companies. And while DFB's print courses are interactive,
most similar products are not.
elearning — including
online and CD-ROM courses — can be highly engaging
if done well. It also reduces or even eliminates the
cost of lost time and production. And it works for even
very large groups. Not all technology-based training
is created equal, however, so here's
what to look for in eLearning
courses. |
| |
| |
Factors for Deciding
on a Training Format |
| |
Price is important, of course, but remember
that the total cost of training includes more
than just the purchase price. It also includes
the wages paid for time away from regular work.
And the value of lost output, i.e., the work
that doesn't get done during the training. Here
are some other things to consider:
- Is the training content current and
accurate?
- Will the training be easy for employees
to use?
- Can employees access the training
easily and reliably?
- Will the training be easy for the
company to administer?
- Does the training engage employees,
or will they be passive?
- Will scheduling the training be difficult?
- Is the training scalable, i.e., can
the company use it to train lots of employees?
|
| |
Compare Instructor-Led
Training |
| |
Instructor-led training, or ILT, is traditional classroom instruction led by
a trainer. It is conducted at a set place and
time, either on- or off-site. Most employees
are very familiar with ILT. And ILT can be ideal
for smaller companies where it's easy to assemble
groups of employees.
ILT is potentially the most interactive and
engaging form of training, if the materials
are sound and it's effectively led by a knowlegeable,
skilled instructor, with groups small enough
for lively discussion.
On the down side, ILT permits the least scheduling
flexibility and causes the most workplace disruption.
Employees must leave their workstations, take
the class, and then return and restart their
work. They sometimes travel off-site. The wage
costs, along with lost production, can easily
exceed the price of the training itself. For
these reasons, the total cost of ILT can be
relatively high.
ILT can be difficult to administer for larger
workforces, where multiple class sessions are
typically required. Schedules must set. Locations
must be found and reserved. Trainers must be
selected, presentation materials prepared and
participation recorded to document compliance.
Companies must also accommodate absentees and
new hires.
In fact, ILT is generally not feasible for
companywide training in a very large organization.
Especially if employees are at different locations
or the training must be completed quickly.
|
| |
Compare Printed Training |
| |
Most employees are familiar with print training
materials and methods. Well-designed workbooks
and newsletters are interesting and informative.
And since employees can use them during downtimes,
there's less workplace disruption and cost to
the company.
However, administering printed materials can
be a challenge for larger companies. The materials
must be copied and distributed. And a way to
track completion and compliance must be developed.
Once they are created, newletters are difficult
to update. Plus, unlike DFB's workbooks and
newsletters, most printed materials are passive.
There is little or no interaction. They are
therefore less likely to engage employees, and
affect knowledge, attitudes and behaviors.
|
| |
Compare eLearning |
| |
With elearning — often called
technology-based training (TBT) — employees can access
courses over networks or with CD-ROM disks.
eLearning courses can be highly interactive, making the
training interesting and improving learning. Employees who
are basically familiar with computers or the Internet find
elearning courses easy to use. They are also easy to administer,
especially online courses, which don’t require CD-ROM
distribution. Online courses can also be delivered through a
learning management system (LMS) that tracks and reports employee progress.
That out-of-pocket cost of eLearning may be
higher than classroom training. But the total
cost could be lower since eLeaning's "anywhere,
"anytime" availability can minimize
lost time and production, and travel costs.
Employees can access courses during downtimes
or off time.
Online courses especially are highly scalable;
large numbers of employees can be trained quickly.
eLearning can replace or complement other training
methods.
|
| |
What to Look for in
eLearning courses |
| |
eLearning has key advantages, but only if
courses are well designed and executed. Many
are not.
Avoid “page-turners,” courses with
screen after screen of text, and little or no
interactivity. Employees will get turned off,
bored and feel like they're wasting their time.
Courses should be substantive and clearly orbanized.
You don't want "fluff." Key messages
should be clear and memorable. Courses should
hit high priority topics. And all information
should be absolutely up-to-date.
Also look for courses that make effective use
of media. Video can be interesting, but requires
lots of bandwidth and is costly to make and
deliver. In many cases it is also not necessary
for good instruction. Training that depends
on audio – such as a narrated PowerPoint
presentation – doesn’t work well
in many work settings. Plus, not all computers
have speakers or headphones. And some people
don’t learn well by just listening.
|
|
|